G.I. Joe: Test Screening

By Christopher Brown on 06.16.2009

The good folks at /Film have recently uncovered a review of the test screening of GIJoe: The Rise of Cobra and, while it’s clearly NOT summer blockbuster material, it’s not exactly the steaming pile that the vast majority of us are expecting.

Apparently, one "Dr. Drew" got the opportunity to review the movie and submitted his own review. Here’s the most interesting bits:

“As far as Sommers’ being shit-canned, I wouldn’t be surprised after seeing the rough cut; it’s not exactly on par with the Paramount/summer blockbuster standard established with Iron Man, Transformers, and Star Trek. Quite frankly, I’d be embarrassed to have Transformers 2 be released, G.I. Joe two weeks later, and both with the Paramount Mountain opening up the credits.

The thing with G.I. Joe is that it tries to have the same spirit and flavor as Transformers–it’s really evident… but an ultimate failure.

The movie has extremely cartoonish and, at times, theatrically silly aspects; for example, over-the-top characters, endless one liners, and visually farfetched technology and set pieces. However, it tries fiercely to ground itself
in reality and in society’s current global climate. It’s with that
grounding that the movie actually redeems itself quite a bit–but not
too much. The G.I. Joes–as an organization–veer off from the hyper
Americana reputation that it’s known for; G.I. Joe is a top secret
branch of NATO that recruits members from all over the world.

Anyways, even though the CG was incomplete in my screening, the action is pretty great. The chase scene with Tatum and Wayans in the Iron Man suits is particularly well done. But rest assured as I’ve noticed a
fear online that those suits play a big role; they don’t, they’re used
in that scene and that scene only. Basically the biggest drain on this
picture is the acting; even Dennis Quaid is cringe-worthy. But the
worst has to be Sienna Miller—do not be surprised if anyone (or
everyone) in the cast get’s Razzie noms. But with Miller’s character,
she wears sunglasses half the movie, delivers normal lines as if
they’re one liners, and just cheeses everything up. Snake Eyes may be
the best part of the movie (not because he doesn’t have any lines,
that’s only a coincidence) as whenever he’s onscreen, he’s doing
something interesting.

There were laughs (some at jokes, some at sight gags, and of course at the expense of Snake Eye’s silence), a few cringes from older audience members (like I said before, the one-liners don’t stop), and a general engagement (but not
really any type of energy or excited in the air). When the picture
ended, there wasn’t really any chatter about the movie. We were given
surveys questioning the film in great detail but most people just flew
through them and left. It was a so-so experience from the audience
perspective. There wasn’t much excitement from the audience afterward.”

…So, there you have it. If this is a fairly accurate review of the film, then it’s clearly not good, but not as awful as we’re expecting. By the way, I made it a point to leave out a few spoilers posted within the review for the sake of the three people who are actually looking forward to the movie. Check out /Film for more of the review.

And, just in case you forgot, here’s the trailer again…

6 Comments


 
2009-06-16 13:06:03
renostar

"it tries fiercely to ground itself
in reality and in society’s current global climate. It’s with that
grounding that the movie actually redeems itself quite a bit–but not
too much. The G.I. Joes–as an organization–veer off from the hyper
Americana reputation that it’s known for; G.I. Joe is a top secret
branch of NATO that recruits members from all over the world."

Whats so wrong with GI Joe being pro American, the Cartoon was Pro American the Comic book series was


 
2009-06-16 13:06:17
nelsonalot


"cartoonish and, at times, theatrically silly aspects; for example,
over-the-top characters, endless one liners, and visually farfetched
technology and set pieces. However, it tries fiercely to ground itself
in reality and in society’s current global climate"

 

Sounds like G.I. Joe to me. Im totally sold.


 
2009-06-16 13:06:17
Skott Stotland
Damn, beat me to it.

 
2009-06-16 13:06:43
Skott Stotland
So based on the review, it's exactly like the cartoon? Good to know they adapted the series faithfully.

 
2009-06-16 15:06:35
Conmaniac89
This Dr. Drew must have been dropped on his head, what an idiot. The TV show contained a reptilian terrorist organization with some of the most outlandish forms of technology ever seen. It was campy, over-the-top and completely ridiculous. That is the charm of it. This movie seems to honor that. Clearly this Dr. Drew has never seen a G.I. Joe cartoon in his life.

 
2009-06-17 17:06:29
david660
...this is gonna be the biggest, smellest turd of the summer.

You must be a Member to post comment Click here to Login

New User? Signup

FRIENDS
  • Ain't It Cool
  • CHUD
  • Comic Book Movie
  • CBR
  • Comics 2 Film
  • Dark Horse
  • DC Comics
  • Devil's Due
  • Fact Pile
  • Film School Rejects
  • First Showing
  • Hero Complex
  • IDW
  • IESB
  • IGN
  • Image
  • io9
  • Joblo
  • Latino Review
  • Marvel
  • Newsarama
  • Oni
  • Slash Film
  • Superhero Hype
  • The Movie Blog
  • Top Cow
  • Topless Robot
  • UGO